Best Baking Stone for Perfectly Baked Bread or Pizza (Quick Guide)

If you are a huge pizza fan and installing a pizza oven in your home sound like a total nuisance, then the best way to satisfy your craving for pizza and make delicious gourmet pizza is by getting one of the best baking stone available in the market. Yes, you heard it right, although it may seem like an unnecessary investment; it can become one of the best kitchen equipment to include into your kitchen arsenal if you are a baking addict and love baking bread or pizza.

What is a Baking Stone?

best-baking-stone

A baking stone, sometimes also referred to as a ‘Pizza stone’ is a thick flat sheet, generally made from a variety of material. The shape can be rectangular, square or round. You can find some of the best baking stone is made of steel, cast iron or ceramic.

A baking stone is commonly used to bake pizza, bread, cookie in an oven. However, some baking stone is suitable to be used in a barbecue pit as well.

Finding a baking stone that is in sync with your requirements is important. Here are some pros and cons of different types of baking stone material which will make it easy to choose one according to your requirements and how you intend to use it.

Baking Stone Types

Clay or Stone

The clay or stone material absorbs moisture as the baking takes place, which results in crisp bread or pizza. The stone can come in a variety of shape and sizes to choose from.

Pros

  • Pizza stone in a variety of shape and size available
  • Results in a crisp pizza crust

Cons

  • Must be preheated for at least 30 minutes
  • Can easily break
  • Hard to clean

Cast Iron

Baking stone made of iron not only can be use to bake a pizza but also suitable for barbecue. If you are looking forward to making pizza without investing in any new equipment, you can use a cast iron skillet.

Pros

  • Heats up quickly
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to maneuver in and out of the oven with the help of handles
  • Don’t easily break or develop crack

Cons

  • It is recommended to use only to 400 Degrees Fahrenheit
  • Can be heavy to move around

Steel

Another great product in the baking industry is steel baking stone. Baking steel conducts heat in a better manner as compared to stone and it can easily cook food more evenly at a low temperature.

Pros

  • Cook food like pizza evenly
  • Won’t break or crack

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Can be heavy to move around

Optimal Usage of Baking Stone

old-stone-pizza-stone

Always preheat the baking stone before use. But it is always better to put the baking stone beforehand and let it preheat with the oven. If you are putting a cold baking stone into a hot oven and depending on the baking stone condition, there are high chances that it will break or crack due to thermal shock.

If you are planning on baking a pizza, it is advised to put the stone nearer the top of the oven, however, if you are baking bread, cookies or other baked goods, you can always orient it in the middle.

A baking stone is naturally nonstick. Therefore, there is no need to use oil on your dough. However, if you are using a peel, you can always sprinkle cornmeal on the bottom.

You should also follow manufacturer’s tips for proper cleaning and usage of the baking stone. If you take good care of the baking stone, it will stay with you for many years to come.

Quick Tips in Choosing Your Best Baking Stone

Before you get your hands on one, you would want to make sure that it will fit your oven perfectly. Measure the width and depth of your oven and take them along as you go to purchase the baking stone.

If you have a natural gas oven, you will need to leave at least one-inch space on the side of the stone for proper circulation. Moreover, if you like the dough to be extra crisp, you can always opt for a thicker stone. Thicker stone have a better heat absorption and evenly distribute the heat to cook the food sitting on top of it.

Cleaning of Baking Stone

If you want your baking stone to perform optimally for many years to come, it is important to keep it clean. The materials use to make a baking stone are porous, and thus it demands proper care. And cleaning is only done after the baking stone is completely cool off.

Never to clean the porous surface of the baking stone with soap. Use a clean sponge and hot water to scrub away the dough and dirt away. Do not soak the baking stone in water and let it dry completely before storing the baking stone away. Also, never let the baking stone go through a drastic temperature change as it will crack the stone due to thermal shock.

Quick Tips for Buying a Baking Stone

bread-stone

There are a large number of pizza stone imitations available in the market that it becomes difficult to get your hands on the right stone. However, you need to steer clear of these fake baking stones.

The imitated pizza stones are just glorified copies of real baking stones, but they do not yield the desired results. What you should look out here are the models that have been designed to move from the oven to table with ease. Moreover, you should remember that no authentic stone is ever dishwasher safe, so do not fall for the marketing gimmick which claims to be dishwasher safe.

Also, choosing a thicker pizza stone is better as thinner the stone, higher are the chances of breaking or cracking over time. The only downside of a thicker baking stone that it needs longer to heat up. Lastly, it must be kept in mind that natural stone is heavy. So if you are buying it online, check whether or not the company levied shipping charges or is it included in the total cost.

Sharing is Caring

sharing-is-caring

Like what you read so far? How about help us to spread this AWESOME post to your friend and family? Your shout-out will help to motivate us to create more great posts for you and everyone else. Thanks for your support!

Check out this post for 'Best Baking Stone for Perfectly Baked Bread or Pizza (Quick Guide)'

Click to Tweet

Our Top Pick for the Best Baking Stone Brands

There are a number of baking stones available in the market, but our highest rated baking stone brands include:

Old Stone Oven Baking Stone

The Old Stone Oven Baking Stone is the standard, rectangular baking stone which is large enough to accommodate different cooking projects easily. With this baking stone, you get more surface area to work on. This baking stone can even be used on a barbecue or in a conventional oven.

What we like about it...

  • Large baking area
  • Perfect for baking bread, cookies, and pizza
  • Specially engineered to conduct heat evenly
  • Unmatched durability

What we don't like...

  • Cannot be used to cook high-fat items
  • Needs high temperature to reach the optimal cooking conditions

Other sizes of baking stone by Old Stone Oven can be found here.

Description

Rating / Grade

Editor Rating


NCS Grade*

B

Lodge Pro-Logic Cast Iron Pizza Pan

A cast iron pizza bake ware can be a great alternative to ceramic baking stone. The Lodge Pro-Logic cast iron pan comes loaded with several benefits that it makes it a must-have kitchen tool. Apart from baking pizza, you can even use it to cook a variety of delicious gourmet such as roasting veggies.

The Lodge cast iron pizza pan is also handy to have it with you during camping or during a barbecue party.

What we like about it...

  • Distributes heat evenly
  • Safe to be used to 400 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Highly durable
  • Ability to withstand high heat
  • Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil formula

What we don't like...

  • Limited lifetime warranty

Other sizes of baking stone by Lodge can be found here.

Description

Rating / Grade

Editor Rating


NCS Grade*

A+

Heritage Black Ceramic Pizza Stone

When it comes to making the perfect pizza or bread, it’s all about the uniformly browned crust. This is what Heritage ceramic pizza stone is known to offer. With the help of this pizza stone, you can easily make a pizza from starch and get consistent results. It is also easy to re-heat the pizza for a much crispier result.

What we like about it...

  • Cleaning is a breeze
  • Top notch quality stone
  • Distributes heat evenly
  • Lightweight

What we don't like...

  • Sometimes, the dough sticks to the stone

Description

Rating / Grade

Editor Rating


NCS Grade*

A-

Conclusion

Whether you are picking up a ceramic baking stone, cast iron stone or a steel one, a good baking stone will make it easy for you to enjoy a great cooking experience. The baking stone featured here are some of the best baking stone brands available in the market right now. The baking stone by Lodge has the highest net customer satisfaction, though.

So go ahead and pick up any one of the baking stone from these brands and you will never find yourself with a burnt crust again. Also, learn how you can fully utilize your baking stone to make bread, cookies, toast or even use it as a warm serving platter. So, are you ready to bake?


Gordan Ladd
 

I've been the cook for my family since 2009, and my passion for food grew stronger each day. Whenever I have time, I love to blog about my culinary experiences and how my kitchen has trained me to become a better cook for my family and friends. Get in touch with me at my G+

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments
Join over 1,000 readers who get the best advice delivered straight to their inbox.
x